Introduction
In this review, I will be evaluating the dining experience at Gustoso Italian Kitchen located in downtown Toronto. Gustoso has been open for over 10 years and is renowned for its authentic homemade Italian cuisine. The restaurant is cozy yet elegant with a decor inspired by classic Tuscan farmhouse aesthetics. Upon entering, guests are greeted with the mouth-watering aromas emanating from the kitchen. In this review, I will be assessing various aspects of the dining experience including food quality, service, ambiance, and value.
Food Quality and Selection
Gustoso prides itself on using only the freshest local and imported ingredients in their dishes. Having dined at Gustoso on multiple occasions, I can confidently say the food never disappoints. The menu changes seasonally to feature the best and most flavorful produce available. On my most recent visit, some appealing starters included burrata served with figs and prosciutto as well as fried calamari. For entrees, popular choices are chicken parmesan, rigatoni Bolognese, and seafood linguine. Gustoso is also renowned for its wood-fired pizzas which are cooked to crispy perfection in their brick oven. The menu also features an extensive selection of homemade pastas, risottos, and steak and seafood options.
All dishes are generous in portion size and bursting with robust Italian flavors. Pasta sauces have the right balance of acidity and sweetness with a velvety texture. Meat and fish are always cooked to order and exceptionally tender. Even simple dishes like polenta are light and creamy having been slow cooked for hours. Desserts should not be missed either, featuring classics like tiramisu and cannoli along with seasonal specialties. During my latest visit, I sampled the panna cotta topped with roasted plums – the creaminess of the panna cotta paired beautifully with the tart sweetness of the plums.
The extensive wine list at Gustoso is also first-rate, focusing on small producers from Italy and featuring many bottles from local vineyards as well. Sommeliers are knowledgeable and helpful in pairing wines with dishes. On a recent visit, I indulged in a full-bodied Brunello di Montalcino with my Osso Buco that was an absolute perfect match. Whether dining alone or for a special occasion, the food at Gustoso is guaranteed to please even the most discerning of palates.
Service
In addition to impeccable cuisine, Gustoso also delivers superb and attentive service. Staff are well-trained, polite, and knowledgeable about both the menu and wine offerings. On busy nights, the open kitchen layout allows for efficient service despite a full dining room. Throughout the meal, servers are consistently checking in without being overbearing. Any questions about dishes or recommendations are answered promptly. The manager also makes rounds to ensure all guests are fully satisfied. On one visit, they graciously changed my entrée upon noticing I did not prefer onions after it was served – no questions asked.
Atmosphere and Ambiance
The atmosphere at Gustoso is elegant yet relaxed. Upon entering, guests are met with the warmth of the wood oven baking bread and other treats. Soft lighting from candle-lit lamps paired with rustic wood furnishings and decor create an intimate setting. The space never feels cramped even when fully booked, in part due to high ceilings and an open kitchen. Live contemporary jazz plays in the background adding to the atmosphere without overwhelming conversation. On balmier nights, patio seating overlooking the street provides an al fresco option to dine under the stars. Overall, the atmosphere fosters conversation while still feeling celebratory and special.
Value
While the quality of ingredients and level of service provided come at a higher price point, I believe the value at Gustoso is excellent. Portions are generous enough that most leave fully satisfied with minimal to no leftovers or doggie bags. One can easily enjoy an appetizer, pasta, entrée, and cocktail or glass of wine for $60-80 per person depending on dish and beverage selection – reasonable for downtown Toronto. Special fixed-price menus for groups provide even better value. Considering the superb fare, the prices are very competitive for the level of authentic Italian cuisine. As with any establishment of this caliber, special occasions are best enjoyed by treating yourself rather than over-focusing on costs alone.
Conclusion
Gustoso Italian Kitchen continues to set the gold standard for authentic Italian dining in Toronto. Ten plus years in, they still consistently deliver impeccable service and seasonal cuisine made entirely from scratch using imported and local ingredients. The comfortable yet upscale ambiance makes it ideal for any gathering from casual weeknight meals to anniversary celebrations. While not the most affordable, Gustoso offers excellent value for money when considering outstanding quality and portion sizes. They have rightly earned their place as a staple neighborhood restaurant and destination for special dining experiences. I have no hesitation highly recommending Gustoso Italian Kitchen and look forward to many return visits.